CAMICB is a more than 25 year old independent professional certification body responsible for developing and delivering the Certified Manager of Community Associations® (CMCA) examination. CAMICB awards and maintains the CMCA credential, recognized worldwide as a benchmark of professionalism in the field of common interest community management. The CMCA examination tests the knowledge, skills, and abilities required to perform effectively as a professional community association manager. CMCA credential holders attest to full compliance with the CMCA Standards of Professional Conduct, committing to ethical and informed execution of the duties of a professional manager.
The CMCA credentialing program carries dual accreditation. The National Commission for Certifying Agencies (NCCA) accredits the CMCA program for meeting its U.S.-based standards for credentialing bodies. The ANSI National Accreditation Board (ANAB) accredits the CMCA program for meeting the stringent requirements of the ISO/IEC 17024 Standard, the international standards for certification bodies. The program's dual accreditation represents compliance with rigorous standards for developing, delivering, and maintaining a professional credentialing program. It underscores the strength and integrity of the CMCA credential.
Privacy Policy: https://www.camicb.org/privacy-policy
Co-op and condo boards must make reasonable accommodations for a host of “protected classes” — or face potentially crippling charges of discrimination. As one New York City co-op board learned recently, those protections extend to religious practices.
Instead of a doorman, this co-op has an electronic keypad beside the front door that requires residents to enter a code to open the door. But one shareholder, an observant Jew, is forbidden from using electric devices on the Sabbath, and so he asked the co-op board to give him a key that opens a door to the basement, where there is a staircase to the lobby. The co-op board told him the basement door was off-limits to residents.
Big mistake, according to the Ask Real Estate column in The New York Times. A request for a key to enter a side door in order to adhere to sincerely held religious belief of Sabbath observance should be honored by every co-op and condo board, unless there is a credible reason why tenants’ use of that entrance is dangerous.
If a co-op or condo board refuses to grant this “extremely reasonable request,” that could be evidence of discrimination, exposing the board to legal liability, says Ali Frick, a partner at the law firm Kaufman Lieb Lebowitz & Frick. “The co-op could be held liable for its neutral policies if they have a disparate impact on a religious group — as its keypad-only policy appears to have.”
A co-op shareholder or condo unit-owner can hire a lawyer to write a letter to the board explaining that he or she observes the Sabbath and that using a keypad prevents keeping religious practice, in effect denying equal access to the building.
“If the co-op flatly rejected your request, you can sue for discrimination because they are effectively making the building unavailable to observant Jews,” says Andrew Lieb, managing partner at his eponymous law firm. The lawsuit could result in a judge ordering the board to grant access to the shareholder, while also awarding him with emotional support damages, other consequential damages, statutory penalties, and attorneys’ fees, Lieb adds.
A 1994 state court decision on this topic that originated in Queens found in favor of the building, because electronic locks were used to deter crime and did not have a discriminatory intent or effect. However, Lieb notes, a different argument could be made based on a more recent federal appellate case, one that states that the co-op’s actions can be discriminatory if they have a negative impact on one group of people.
The only excuse for this co-op’s refusal to give the shareholder a key to the basement door would be to show that the refusal involved no discriminatory intent and no discriminatory effect.
“Which is impossible,” Lieb says, “given that (the refusal) eliminated observant Jews from entering their housing.”
The bottom line: Boards must not only grant reasonable accommodations, they must also treat all residents equally.
The rise in interest rates has pushed a record number of co-op buyers to make all-cash offers, especially at the high end of the market. Some co-op boards have begun demanding all-cash purchases exclusively — a tactic for ensuring the financial solidity of buyers while enhancing the building’s aura of exclusivity. But there are downsides.
One is the the effect cash-only policies have on the pool of potential buyers. “The question for the prospective purchaser is whether the advantage of such a board policy outweighs the disadvantage,” Kevin Mcconnell, of counsel at the law firm Himmelstein, McConnell, Gribben & Joseph, tells Brick Underground. “The advantage is that the other tenant-shareholders are not burdened by the obligation to pay monthly maintenance and mortgage; only the former. The disadvantage is that it narrows the potential buyer market and drives down the price.”
Adds Deanna Kory, a broker at Corcoran: “The only downside is that there’s a limited number of people who can truly afford to pay all cash and have the financial requirements that are required. When you go to sell, your buyer pool will be far more restricted, so it may take longer to sell and find the right type of buyer who can pass the board.”
Another downside is that a cash-only policy could actually be a way of masking unseen, and unpleasant, financial problems. Is the reserve fund running dry? Are costly repairs overdue? Have monthly maintenance fees been rising?
To find answers, potential buyers and their brokers should take a close look at the co-op’s documents — past board meetings minutes, bylaws, offering plan, maintenance trends, repair history, scheduled repairs and upgrades, and so forth. Such investigations can reveal that things are not as they appear.
For example, Curbedstumbled upon a $99,900 studio apartment in a middle-class co-op located on Billionaire’s Row, a luxe stretch of developments in Midtown Manhattan. Seems like a great deal right?
Not so fast. That co-op at 100 West 57th St. sits on land the building doesn’t own, and the long-term land lease is set to expire next year, which could expose shareholders to a sharp rise in rent. If it’s sharp enough, residents fear the co-op could dissolve and its shareholders would turn into tenants. Not the kind of building you want to buy into, especially with an all-cash offer.
In a footnote, a bill in the state Legislature sought to cap the amount landowners could raise rent on their land. The bill, opposed by the Real Estate Board of New York among others, failed to gain traction and died a quiet death. A group advocating for the bill, the Ground Lease Co-op Coalition, said that it will keep pushing for the legislation to protect middle-income shareholders in the city’s 100 land-lease co-ops from exorbitant increases.
New research by academics at the London School of Economics (LSE) and the University of Essex in the UK suggests that hiring bias against older workers is resistant to subtle nudging, and that efforts to address systemic discrimination must be more direct.
Across five studies, each with randomly recruited UK participants, the study team evaluated the effect of decision bundling on the selection rates of older candidates in technology roles. Sometimes called volume hiring, companies with numerous entry-level roles, such as technicians, retail and service roles, may use group hiring to offset recruiting and training costs.
The researchers ran thousands of hiring simulations with potential recruiters, finding that younger candidates were twice as likely to be hired as older candidates with the same relative experience. Only when hiring companies were explicit about the value of older workers and diversity was the bias against older workers eliminated.
Conducted by Daniel Jolles, Marie Juanchich and Beatrice Piccoli from the University of Essex, the study “Too Old to Be a Diversity Hire: Choice Bundling Shown to Increase Gender-Diverse Hiring Decisions Fails to Increase Age Diversity” explored the impact of hiring in groups to overcome bias against older workers. While the bundling method has been shown in previous gender studies to effectively increase gender diversity, this method failed to increase age diversity.
In the study, participants were shown younger candidates between ages 22 and 34 (median age 25) and older candidates between 61 and 67 (median age 64) and asked to make hiring decisions. Across the five studies, the team varied the experience level and qualifications, where the older candidate was slightly less qualified or equally qualified. The results showed that participants were more than twice as likely to select younger candidates than older candidates with equal experience.
These findings affirm the obstacles faced by many older job candidates, including reskilling older workers into new technologies. For older workers who want to switch careers or reskill, the effort might fail to deliver benefits if they are viewed more critically than younger workers or dismissed altogether. The findings also showed a general need for greater awareness about the underrepresentation of older workers in technology firms.
The Power of Explicit Statements
Age is one diversity characteristic that has received relatively little DEI attention. However, low participation of older adults (aged 50+) in the workforce is recognized as a key risk to productivity in many countries. Older workers are often more likely to be out of work and find it much harder to get back into employment due to routine age-related bias in hiring, according to the report.
In a further attempt to offset this, the authors also tested the impact of adding a diversity statement as part of the hiring process. According to the report, participants were asked to read a diversity statement before selecting the best candidate to hire based on gender and age (assuming candidates had the same skills and experience).
The statement tested in the first pilot study, “The company strongly values diversity and is committed to achieving diversity within its teams, including gender, race, ethnicity and age diversity,” increased the value of women candidates but did not increase the value of older candidates.
The second pilot study used a more explicit diversity statement to emphasize the need for older talent to increase age diversity, “The company strongly values diversity and is committed to achieving diversity within its teams. To achieve this, the company seeks to increase representation of women, older and Non-White employees.” The revised statement successfully increased the value of both women and older candidates.
However, using the diversity statement in a bundling scenario failed to increase the selection of older candidates. According to the study, “the statement effectively over-powered any potential bundling effect, such that fewer older candidates were chosen in the choice bundling condition than the isolated choice condition when the statement was present. This is consistent with prior studies that show an explicit diversity statement reversed the effect of choice bundling on the selection of women candidates.”
What Companies Must Do
These findings suggest that attitudes and environment are essential to decision-making. Therefore, recruiting and hiring processes should include multiple approaches and combinations to achieve greater age diversity.
“Our research shows considerable bias against older job candidates,” said Dr. Jolles, behavioural scientist at LSE’s The Inclusion Initiative and lead author for the study. “While many firms try to increase diversity by changing their recruitment processes with nudging techniques or blinding applications, firms that choose to be explicit with recruiters about their diversity goals are more likely to achieve them.”
Additionally, the study team found that when a company clearly stated a desire to increase age diversity through hiring more older adults, recruiter bias against older candidates was effectively removed.
“We would encourage companies to experiment and review their practices to find what works,” said co-author Professor Marie Juanchich, with the Department of Psychology at the University of Essex.
By Madeline Hay, CAMICB’s Director of Exam Administration
The Community Association Managers International Certification Board (CAMICB) is poised to usher in a new era for the Certified Manager of Community Associations (CMCA) exam, offering a revamped blueprint that mirrors the dynamic landscape of association management across the globe. These changes, stemming from a thorough job analysis study conducted between 2021 and 2022, reflect an evolution in the core competencies required by community association managers worldwide.
Job Analysis
Job analysis is the cornerstone of ensuring that the CMCA exam remains an authoritative assessment tool, reflecting the contemporary roles and responsibilities of association managers. This comprehensive study involved a multifaceted approach, dissecting the complexities of association management to chart a revised course for the credential.
The task of redefining the blueprint through job analysis was a colossal undertaking spanning 18 months. The comprehensive study involved 13 project phases, including reviews of over 100 primary source documents, survey responses from 3,000 managers around the world, and more than 90 hours of collaborative meetings with 55 subject matter expert volunteers. Notably, 20 of these experts were sourced internationally, reflecting the global significance and diverse perspectives encompassed in this endeavor. This validation process ensured that the CMCA exam blueprint aligns with the real-world experiences and challenges faced by professionals in the field.
Updated Blueprint
The job analysis study resulted in an updated blueprint that encapsulates the requirements of modern community association management. Notable changes include a reorganization of job tasks and knowledge into six principal categories compared to the previous eight, allowing for a more cohesive representation of the industry’s nuances.
For instance, content previously segregated into distinct categories, such as “Budgets, Reserves, Investments, and Assessments” and “Financial Controls,” will now be consolidated under broader headings like “Financial Management” and “Risk Management.” This streamlined approach better reflects the multifaceted nature of association management, presenting a more cohesive and holistic assessment framework for aspiring CMCA candidates.
One of the findings of the job analysis study was a significant emphasis on meetings and events in the daily responsibilities of early-career managers. Consequently, the exams will see an expansion of the “Meetings and Events” domain from 10% to 18%. Furthermore, “Property Maintenance” and “Risk Management” will increase by 3% and 4% respectively, while “Contracting” reduces from 13% to 10%.
Notably, the human resources domain, constituting 6% of the current exam content, will no longer feature in the revised blueprint.
Current Blueprint (Remains Until December 2024)
Topic Area
% of Exam
1. Meetings
10
2. Governance, Legal and Ethical Conduct
23
3. Budgets, Reserves, Investments, and Assessments
15
4. Financial Controls
11
5. Risk Management and Insurance
11
6. Property Maintenance
11
7. Contracting
13
8. Human Resources
6
Total
100
Updated Blueprint (Starting in December 2024)
Topic Area
% of Exam
1. Meetings and Events
18
2. Governance and Compliance
23
3. Financial Management
20
4. Risk Management
15
5. Contracting
10
6. Property Maintenance
14
Total
100
The CMCA Candidate Handbook and the CMCA Study Guide have been updated to reflect the revised blueprint. The current Handbook and Study Guide – valid through December 2024 – will remain on www.camicb.org through the end of December. The updated Study Guide and Handbook are also now available on the website. After December 2024, only the updated Study Guide and Handbook will be available.
Managers planning to test before December 2024 should refer only to the current Handbook and Study Guide. Managers planning to test after December 2024 should utilize only the updated Handbook and Study Guide.
Looking Ahead
The redefined CMCA exam blueprint, meticulously curated through a comprehensive job analysis study, embodies CAMICB’s commitment to elevating industry standards.
These changes are not merely cosmetic but serve a foundational purpose—to ensure that the CMCA exam genuinely reflects the essentials of community management worldwide. The blueprint revisions align the exam content with the ever-evolving needs of the profession, encapsulating the industry’s best practices, irrespective of geographic nuances.
Stay tuned as CAMICB offers more in-depth exploration of the blueprint throughout the next year leading up to the December 2024 change, symbolizing a leap forward in certifying the finest professionals in community association management.
Questions regarding the launch of updated forms of the CMCA examination may be forwarded to info@camicb.org or call 703-970-9300.
It’s a delicate dance when a co-op shareholder or condo-unit owner requests to see board documents. The board has an obligation to be transparent, yet it doesn’t want delicate information leaving the building and getting into the wrong hands.
This dance played out recently at a Brooklyn co-op after the board fired the long-time super, who promptly filed a lawsuit against the board. The case was settled out of court, and when the shareholders asked for more information, the board told them only that the final cost was $15,000 and the other details were confidential. Is a board required to reveal the details of such a legal settlement?
Co-op boards have the right to enter into a confidential settlement with an employee, replies the Ask Real Estate column in The New York Times. But that doesn’t mean shareholders can’t find out more.
“While there’s no explicit requirement for the board to detail every expense, they are obligated to provide a general accounting of how funds are used,” says Joseph Colbert, managing attorney at Colbert Law.
Settlements with confidentiality provisions are common, and the terms of this settlement, including the amount paid to the aggrieved super, can remain secret — depending on what the lawyers negotiated. But even if shareholders don’t have the right to know about all of the settlement’s terms and conditions, the co-op board is still accountable to them, and it cannot hide the financial impact of the entire lawsuit.
Shareholders can review the co-op’s audited financial statements, says Leni Morrison Cummins, chair of the condominium and cooperative practice at the law firm Cozen O’Connor. These statements will reflect the cost of the legal action. There should be a footnote explaining this, but it might be vague. The auditor reviews the books and records, and also requires a legal confirmation letter from the board’s attorney describing all pending or threatened litigation, claims and assessments, during the audit period, Cummins adds.
If the audited statements are not available yet, co-op shareholders have a right under the Business Corporation Law to request to review the co-op’s books and records, as long as the request is made in good faith and for a proper purpose.
This right is buttressed by recent case law. In two closely watched 2017 lawsuits covered by Habitat, the courts ruled that residents have broad rights to examine board documents — and make electronic copies — while boards are allowed to demand nondisclosure agreements to keep the records from circulating outside the builidng. Such NDAs are designed to protect against bad-faith “fishing” expeditions by disgruntled shareholders or unit-owners who are looking for information that can be used against the board.
“The rights of an owner to review books and records must be balanced with maintaining the integrity of confidential information,” Rob Braverman, a principal at the law firm Braverman Greenspun, told Habitat after the 2017 lawsuits.
A large co-op in Queens never enacted a smoke-free policy, though the proprietary lease prohibits residents from allowing odors to travel from their apartment into neighboring apartments and common areas. A shareholder living above the elderly resident of a rent-stabilized apartment has been inundated with the downstairs neighbors’ cigarette smoke. After sending notices to the smoker for years and threatening to bring an eviction case, the property manager finally got the rent-stabilized apartment’s owner to agree to install smoke-abatement equipment in the unit. Ten weeks later, nothing has happened. The exasperated shareholder upstairs has a question: “What do I do now?”
Not much, replies the Ask Real Estate column in The New York Times. The co-op board, through its property manager, has made some effort to abate the smoke, and your neighbor has protections against eviction as a rent-stabilized tenant — both of which work against your chances of success in housing court.
“No one has a right to let smoke emanate into your apartment, but when it’s a rent-stabilized tenant, it makes it more difficult to take legal action,” says Lisa Smith, a partner at the law firm Smith, Gambrell & Russell.
You could bring the co-op to court, but it is covered by the business judgment rule, which protects co-op board actions that are made in good faith, making a legal claim difficult. Ultimately, it’s the apartment owner who is responsible for eliminating the odor.
Even if your board were to pass a no-smoking policy, it likely wouldn’t help your situation if it were enacted after your neighbor moved in. Rent-stabilized tenants typically enjoy the privileges they had when they arrived in the building, a practice known as grandfathering.
You can request that the co-op board hire a company that administers smoke tests, which can determine how and where the smoke is entering your apartment. The co-op should also gain access to your neighbor’s apartment to perform this test and make any necessary repairs, such as blocking avenues for smoke to escape the unit.
As for that promised smoke-abatement equipment, don’t get your hopes up. Adam Leitman Bailey, a lawyer who has handled cases involving smoke odors, says that, in his experience, “That machine has never worked to solve any case.”
Sadly, this shareholder’s best hope might be a suggestion that involves neither the courts nor technology: ask the smoker downstairs to open her windows when she lights up.
In his commencement speech for the 2024 graduating class of Dartmouth College, tennis great Roger Federer gives a master class in emotional intelligence.
This time, it’s not for a tennis victory. Rather, it’s for his remarkable commencement address, which he delivered on Sunday to the 2024 graduating class of Dartmouth College.
Federer’s speech is an amazing case study in emotional intelligent speaking: It’s funny, motivating, inspiring. It’s emotionally moving. And most important, it has valuable takeaways–not just for graduates, but for anyone trying to succeed at life.
If you have 20 minutes, I highly recommend you listen to the speech in its entirety. But Federer himself summed up the speech in three main points and 14 words:
Effortless is a myth.
It’s only a point.
Life is bigger than the court.
Let’s analyze each point, and see how you can apply them to your life and business. (If you find value in this article, you might be interested in my free emotional intelligence course, which delivers a new rule directly to your inbox every day for a week.)
Effortless is a myth
Federer said he would often become frustrated when he heard others say his play was “effortless.”
“The truth is I had to work very hard to make it look easy,” Federer said. “I got that reputation because my warmups at the tournaments were so casual that people didn’t think I’d been training hard. But I had been training hard, before the tournament when no one was watching.”
Federer went on to explain how hard work is the foundation of confidence and success, not only in tennis, but in life. Talent is not just a gift, he said; it’s also grit. Discipline, patience, trust in yourself, loving the process, managing your life–all of this is part of talent, and everyone has to work at developing these abilities.
I can definitely attest to the wisdom of these words. For years, I’ve studied the lives and habits of elite athletes, teams, coaches, and business leaders. I’ve discovered two things along the way:
1. Nothing is ever as easy as it looks.
2. When it comes to reaching your goals, it’s extremely helpful to know ahead of time the scope of practice and effort needed to become great at something.
For example, I remember a great story Amazon founder Jeff Bezos told about how long it takes to learn to do a handstand. Most people think it takes two weeks. In reality, it takes closer to six months.
You can apply that principle to almost anything: learning a sport or an instrument, building a successful business, even writing a great email.
“From this day forward, some people are going to assume that because you graduated from Dartmouth, it all is going to come easy for you,” Federer continued.
“And you know what? Let them believe that–as long as you don’t.”
It’s only a point
Federer’s next point is an especially insightful one.
He explains that in the 1,526 singles matches he played in his career, he won almost 80 percent of those matches. However, he won only 54 percent of points in those matches.
“In other words, even top-ranked tennis players win barely more than half of the points they play,” Federer continued. “When you lose every second point on average, you learn not to dwell on every shot. You teach yourself to think, ‘It’s only a point.’ “
In the game of life, Federer explained, you will lose “points,” over and over. But this mindset helps you overcome self-doubt and negative energy. It frees you to fully commit to what comes next with intensity, clarity, and focus.
“You want to become a master at overcoming hard moments,” said Federer. “That is, to me, the sign of a champion, the best in the world. And, not the best because they win every point. It’s because they know they’ll lose again and again, and have learned how to deal with it.
“You move on, be relentless, adapt, and grow.”
Life is bigger than the court
Federer next related how important it was for him to have a life beyond tennis. He wanted a rewarding life full of travel, culture, friendships, and family, all the while never forgetting where he came from.
Federer also wanted to serve others. It’s why he began a foundation at the age of 22 to help provide education to people in countries with fewer resources. At that age, Federer explained, he didn’t feel ready for anything other than tennis. But motivated by his mother, he took a chance and figured it out.
And while Federer says tennis provided so many memories, his off-court experiences have been just as impactful.
“Tennis, like life, is a team sport,” Federer continues. “Yes, you stand alone on your side of the net, but your success depends on your team, your coaches, your teammates, even your rivals. All these influences help you to make you who you are.”
Federer then credited his parents, his wife, and his four children for encouraging him, supporting him, and bringing joy to his life.
“Graduates, I know the same is true for you, your parents, your families,” Federer continued. “They made the sacrifices to get you here, and they have shared your triumphs and your struggles. They will always, always be in your corner … The friends who have pushed you and supported you to become the best versions of yourself.”
This is so true. As the famous poet John Donne wrote, “No man is an island.”
Recognizing that can not only help you get the emotional support you need when times get rough, it will make the victories more sweet, too.
Federer went on to sum up his entire speech, repeating those 14 key words:
Effortless is a myth.
It’s only a point.
Life is bigger than the court.
A true master class in emotional intelligence–and the best graduation speech I’ve ever heard.
Have you ever met someone and liked them immediately? Not in a romantic way, but in a connected, warm, “gosh, I’d love to have coffee with that person” way?
Some people are just likable. Others seem to think well of them without much effort on their part. And being likable can have its benefits, says Jenny Woo, founder and CEO of Mind Brain Emotion and creator of 52 Essential Relationship Skills, an emotional intelligence training game. “It does have a payoff, and it matters,” she says, noting that being likable helps you connect with others. When you can do that, you can communicate better and connect with people who are different from you, both of which can help you be more effective in the workplace.
But there’s a fine line between working on your likability and ease of connection versus people-pleasing, which can be detrimental, she adds. And it might not be surprising that likable people have some habits and traits that help them connect.
In the workplace, Woo says likability increases when people give credit where it’s due. “It’s about sharing the spotlight,” she says. While someone might not be conventionally gregarious and outgoing or might have a difficult personality, giving credit to someone who worked on a project or came up with an idea makes them feel valued—and that goes a long way toward likability.
THEY ARE AUTHENTIC
Showing up as who you truly are can enhance your likability, says executive coach J. Victor McGuire, founder of Coaching for Everyone, a nonprofit organization that offers affordable, high-quality coaching programs to BIPOC (Black, Indigenous, and people of color) individuals. “People are generally drawn to individuals who are genuine and who are transparent,” he says. “Coaches who are authentic in their interactions, for example, seem to be more trustworthy and relatable.” Authentic people may be seen as more trustworthy and reliable, too.
THEY ARE CARING AND EMPATHETIC
McGuire says that people tend to like others who are caring and empathetic. When you show other people that you care about their well-being and feelings, you become more likable, he says, adding, “This helps build a strong, trusting relationship with others.”
THEY ARE GOOD AND ACTIVE LISTENERS
Being a good listener and helping people feel heard also enhances likability, King says. He builds rapport through listening and being curious. “[N]ever interrupt unless you are adding on to what they are saying and agreeing with them—and after you interrupt, you have to hand the microphone back to them. Many interruptions are self-serving,” he says. Another tip: Make sure that you are asking at least one question about the other person for every three times you talk about yourself. “This helps maintain balance, and creates the feeling that you actually care,” he says.
THEY’RE GOOD COMMUNICATORS
People tend to like you more when you’re straight with them—even if the news isn’t great. That’s according to a 2023 study published in the Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, which also reveals that ambiguity can hurt your likability, as it may be perceived as a way to dodge the truth. The study found that when people are ambiguous with their language, even when it’s to “soften the blow,” others make personality judgments about them, finding them less warm, less extraverted, and more cautious.
WHAT’S NOT TO LIKE ABOUT LIKABILITY?
There is an important point about likability that can’t be ignored, Woo mentions. It’s an area where bias can creep in. “You absolutely have to be mindful” of stereotypes and biases that exist, she says, “whether [they’re related to] your gender, your preferences, your culture, heritage, how you look, your race.”
Some people feel like they need to “code switch” or hide or change some aspect of themselves to fit in or not seem threatening. That can take its toll, Woo says. However, that awareness can also help you handle issues when they arise—and leave a memorable impression when you break through stereotypes or preconceived notions and achieve connection and understanding, she says.
And that concept cuts both ways. We should look for such biases in ourselves. “Being open to new ideas is also about being open to other people’s ideas and opinions,” Woo explains. When we find ourselves not liking a person, it’s important to explore why. Sometimes there are legitimate reasons, Woo adds, but sometimes the issues are rooted in different cultures, communication styles, or other issues that can be overcome when we’re aware of them.
New CEOs often face challenges when trying to assert their leadership style. This 3-step plan can help managers rebuild relationships with an alienated team.
Accepting the role of CEO to a national nonprofit, Liza felt energized by the board’s challenge to evolve the organization’s mission and programming. Anticipating heavy work demands, she set early expectations with her team: she would work half days on Fridays and take a monthly mental health day to reflect and restore. Liza cited research reinforcing her decision and felt pride modeling her leadership values. After talking with her team, though, she noticed hesitation, even detecting long sighs and an eye roll. She wondered, “Are they trying to sabotage me?”
In our experience coaching hundreds of executives, Liza’s story is common. Many new-in-role leaders readily assert their leadership style, prepared to deliver on promises they made while interviewing to influence the trajectory of the organization. If a leader doesn’t fully understand the context, culture, and people within the existing organization, however, their visionary zeal can land poorly. When early mistakes aren’t addressed quickly, they can fester, destroying initial goodwill and leading to irreparably harmed relationships.
If you’ve stepped into a new role and find yourself confused by the dynamics or sense you’re losing the support of your team, here are three steps you can take:
RESIST DOUBLING DOWN AND DEFENDING
When you sense your actions are received poorly, it’s tempting to justify your reasoning and explain your goals further. Liza presumed the staff didn’t understand the benefits of her self-care schedule so she moved to prove and defend the benefits of her reduced work week. When this created more distance versus alignment with her staff, Liza felt at risk.
Our human wiring for survival means we often instinctively move to fight or flee when we sense the threat that we don’t belong or our perspective isn’t valued. Liza “fought” by providing more data justifying her good judgment, essentially asserting “I’m right!” which only further distanced her from her team.
Through coaching, Liza saw how doubling down and defending sabotaged her. We practiced simple breathing exercises to calm her nervous system when her leadership decisions were threatened. We also explored questions that helped her widen her aperture and move into curiosity and connection mode:
How might my team be trying to help me?
What am I not seeing that they see?
How can I hold this more lightly?
In a more calm, open, and measured state, Liza felt ready to learn instead of defend, a powerful first step for any leader experiencing threat in their new role.
INVITE OTHER PERSPECTIVES AND ENGAGE WITH CURIOSITY
Once Liza calmed, she understood that different perspectives might be at play. She knew that being a “martyr” led to burnout and resentment, so her boundary setting was reasonable. She also saw that asserting her nonnegotiables left the team without room to share their concerns; they felt dismissed, as though Liza was asserting, “This is what I need: ADAPT!”
In her next leadership team meeting she shared, “I realize in my haste to be honest, I failed to ask how that landed and what your needs and boundaries are. Can we discuss more?” When they explored the issue, rich information emerged: worries about overload in her absence, concerns she was abusing her authority by following a different schedule than the team, and fears she would be unavailable for urgent decisions. Reviewing these insights together, the team could determine how to honor self-care as an organizational norm while simultaneously ensuring equity and effectiveness.
When you’re new-in-role and feeling undercurrents of resentment and pushback, the most important first stance is curiosity. Take advantage of team or direct report 1:1 time to ask deeper questions and be genuinely curious about how your proposed changes are perceived. Invite humility into your leadership: you’ve been hired for your knowledge and experience, but your team can offer invaluable wisdom and perspective.
BALANCE PATIENCE WITH URGENCY WHEN APOLOGIZING
Once Liza confirmed that her approach clashed with organizational norms and alienated people, Liza knew she needed to apologize. First, though, she had to progress through the emotional stages of 1) feeling hurt by being misunderstood to 2) feeling ganged up on, to 3) anger that her intentions were misconstrued. When Liza acknowledged her deepest negative feelings, she felt prepared to move forward effectively.
Once you recognize a miscalculation, it’s tempting to “fix” it and apologize immediately. A “good” apology, though, has several steps according to Marjorie Ingall and Susan McCarthy’s book, Sorry, Sorry, Sorry: The Case for Good Apologies. First, listen; successful apologies ensure the other person knows they’ve been heard and understood. Then, explicitly say, “I am sorry.” Don’t couch apologies by distancing your responsibility, e.g. “I’m sorry you felt that way.” Also, explicitly share what you heard and learned from follow-up conversations to demonstrate your desire to grow and improve, e.g. “I see I asserted strong opinions that felt incongruent with the existing culture and it created understandable resistance. I should have been more thoughtful in my approach.”
Finally, “repair” relations with your team by articulating what you will do differently based on what you learned. In Liza’s case, she agreed that her boundaried schedule would be an experiment for three months and could be adjusted if it didn’t work out; she agreed to make herself available virtually for pressing decisions when away. And, she established a task force to implement restorative days that could be available to all employees.
By taking time to fully comprehend her misstep, give a straightforward apology, and make it right with her team, Liza learned from her mistakes. She honored her values while also adapting to the needs of the organization to build trust and connection.
The vision, ideas, and enthusiasm leaders bring to new roles are inspiring. It’s likely, though, that while finding their footing in a new context, leaders will misstep. This can erode credibility and even limit tenure. Missteps that are thoughtfully acknowledged and tended to, however, can deepen trust in a leader’s capacity and propel the organization forward.
Deloitte’s 2024 Gen Z and Millennial Survey spotlights two generations of workers grappling with pressure: financial insecurity, high stress levels and mounting climate anxiety. According to Elizabeth Faber, Deloitte’s global chief people and purpose officer, they are also considering how rapidly evolving technology like generative AI will impact their jobs and longer-term career decisions. These stresses affect their career choices.
Among the most interesting findings of the global research—which surveyed nearly 23,000 respondents across 44 countries—is that a decent percentage of Gen Zs and millennials are likely to take on part- or full-time paying “side jobs” in addition to their primary jobs. About 45% of Gen Zs and 36% of millennials in this year’s survey say they have side jobs ranging from selling products or services online to flexible “gig” work like ridesharing or food delivery, pursuing artistic ambitions or working in a restaurant or retail job, among others.
The rise of side jobs among Gen Zs and millennials
The survey found that the top reason Gen Zs and millennials work side jobs is to relieve financial pressures. This is not surprising, given that the survey finds that the cost of living is their top concern for the third year running. Plus, more than half of both generations live paycheck-to-paycheck.
“Employers have an important role to play here, as they have the ability and responsibility to support the financial wellbeing of their employees, particularly during uncertain times,” Faber explains.
Faber adds that the “side hustle” has some upsides for Gen Zs and millennials, such as allowing them to monetize a hobby, develop new skills and relationships, and positively impact their community.
“Employers should be mindful of this as it will likely require offering flexibility so that employees have time to pursue their passions outside of work,” she says. “Ultimately, this is an important way for organizations to support their employees’ wellbeing and growth.”
What Gen Zs and millennials want from work
Especially in light of the prevalence of side jobs, work/life balance remains the top priority for both Gen Zs and millennials when choosing an employer. Maintaining a positive work/life balance is also the top thing they admire in their peers, well above other traditional success markers such as titles and material possessions.
That has yielded mixed results for return-to-office policies, with some Gen Zs and millennials reporting benefits like improved engagement and collaboration, while others are experiencing increased stress and decreased productivity.
Stress levels and mental health continue to be a concern, although there are some signs of improvement. Only about half of respondents rate their mental health as good or extremely good. And up to 40% of Gen Zs and 25% of millennials say they feel stressed all or most of the time (down from 46% and 39%, respectively, in 2023). While work is a big driver of this unease, respondents emphasize their finances and the health and welfare of their families as the top contributors to stress.
While employers need to focus on meeting the mental health needs of Gen Zs and millennials, they also should prioritize how they’re helping their workforce connect to the meaning of their work. Nearly nine in 10 Gen Zs and millennials say purpose is important to their job satisfaction, and they are increasingly likely to turn down work or employers that don’t align with their values.
“Gen Zs and millennials expect a lot from their employers and from business more broadly,” Faber says. She adds that what they are asking for is what most employees in the workforce, regardless of age, likely want: meaningful work within purpose-driven organizations, the flexibility to balance work and personal priorities, supportive workplaces that foster better mental health, and opportunities to learn and grow in their careers.
“Employers who work to get these things right will have a more satisfied, productive, engaged and agile workforce—one better prepared to adapt to a rapidly transforming world,” she says.