CAMICB is a more than 25 year old independent professional certification body responsible for developing and delivering the Certified Manager of Community Associations® (CMCA) examination. CAMICB awards and maintains the CMCA credential, recognized worldwide as a benchmark of professionalism in the field of common interest community management. The CMCA examination tests the knowledge, skills, and abilities required to perform effectively as a professional community association manager. CMCA credential holders attest to full compliance with the CMCA Standards of Professional Conduct, committing to ethical and informed execution of the duties of a professional manager.
The CMCA credentialing program carries dual accreditation. The National Commission for Certifying Agencies (NCCA) accredits the CMCA program for meeting its U.S.-based standards for credentialing bodies. The ANSI National Accreditation Board (ANAB) accredits the CMCA program for meeting the stringent requirements of the ISO/IEC 17024 Standard, the international standards for certification bodies. The program's dual accreditation represents compliance with rigorous standards for developing, delivering, and maintaining a professional credentialing program. It underscores the strength and integrity of the CMCA credential.
Privacy Policy: https://www.camicb.org/privacy-policy
The field of community association management offers great potential for professionals who have experience in people-centric roles. If you’ve worked in the hospitality or service industry, this might be a career path to consider. And whether you’re new to the field or have been working as a community association manager for some time, it’s worth learning about how the Certified Manager of Community Associations (CMCA) credential can help you take your career to the next level.
The Community Associations Institute (CAI) estimates that as of 2018, there are approximately 355,000 community associations in the United States housing over 74 million residents. That’s 11 million more residents than just a decade ago. In fact, one in four people in the U.S. lives in a community association. There are approximately 8,000 community association management companies and up to 60,000 off and on-site community association managers in the U.S. alone. As the number of people living in community associations increases, so too does the need for community association managers.
Job prospects are excellent, especially for community association managers who hold a professional designation. It’s estimated that up to 26 percent of all ownership housing is in one of the three basic types of community associations. As of May 2020, the median annual wage for community association managers was just over $59,500. As job prospects and wages vary from state to state, it’s a good idea to check out your area’s particulars.
CMCA – The Essential Credential
The Certified Manager of Community Associations (CMCA) credential key to building a successful career in community association management. It signifies to employers you’re competent in specific management practices and are committed to professional excellence, ethical business standards, and continuing education. Employers are always on the lookout for dedicated professionals, and the CMCA credential after your name often makes the difference between whether or not you land the all-important first interview.
The CMCA credential is highly accessible:
It can be achieved with a limited investment of time and money on your part.
It takes a few days of prerequisite course work, some time for study, and one day for the exam.
Its relatively low cost is a great investment in your future.
Earning the CMCA credential opens the door to higher earnings—on average 20 percent more—than non-credentialed community association managers. It is also a great way to build your professional expertise and image.
The CMCA program is dual accredited. The National Commission for Certifying Agencies (NCCA) accredits the CMCA program for meeting its U.S.-based standards for credentialing bodies. The ANSI National Accreditation Board (ANAB) accredits the CMCA program for meeting the stringent requirements of ISO/IEC 17024 Standard, the international standards for certification bodies. The program’s dual accreditation represents compliance with rigorous standards for developing, delivering, and maintaining a professional credentialing program. It makes the CMCA credential one of a small number of dual-accredited credentialing bodies and the only accredited certification for community association management professionals around the world. It is a great source of pride and a strong testament to the strength and value of the CMCA credential.?
An Exciting Career Path with A lot of Potential
Life as a community association manager can vary day-to-day. Managers work closely with residents and Board members, make site visits to the community, hire and supervise vendors, interact with community leaders, and so much more. Not only do you earn a decent living, but you’re constantly learning new things and meeting interesting people from all walks of life. The odds of becoming bored on the job are slim—there are just too many different and interesting things to do!
Becoming a Certified Manager of Community Associations is not merely a designation; it can lead to the career journey of a lifetime. It elevates your credibility as a community association manager and makes employers more confident in hiring you. Finally, it offers you a wealth of opportunity, stability, and growth potential in an exciting career that currently shows no sign of slowing down.
Construction defects are nothing new to the buyers of New York City condominiums. What is new is that New York State recently revised its century-old rules on what’s known as fraudulent conveyance. The new Uniform Voidable Transactions Act, which went into effect on April 4, 2020, has just produced its first court ruling — and it’s good news for condo boards and unit-owners battling to recoup the cost of fixing construction defects.
In the recent decision, Justice Andrea Masley of the Commercial Division of New York State Supreme Court ruled that the sponsor of the condo conversion at 11 Beach St. in Tribeca must set aside $1.1 million — what’s known as a “pre-judgment attachment” — to satisfy any future awards to the condo board in an ongoing lawsuit over defects in the renovation work. The 11-story building was built in 1900 as offices, and the sponsor, HFZ Capital Group, began the condo conversion in 2014, with prices starting at $5.3 million.
“This decision was very good for us,” says Jeffrey Schwartz, a partner at the law firm Schwartz Sladkus Reich Greenberg Atlas, which is representing the condo board in the ongoing litigation. “Our clients still have to show that they’re entitled to the money, but the purpose of the pre-judgment attachment is to preserve a share of the proceeds from the sale of apartment 3-B. If the sponsor had been allowed to get rid of that apartment, that would have resulted in us not having any money to pursue. That asset would have been gone.”
When mistakes are made in co-op and condo board elections, the whole process can be tainted and litigation can result. That’s what happened in the case of Roberts v. WVH Housing Corp.
WVH, a New York City cooperative, has a seven-member board, and at the 2021 election four positions were open. Shareholders were able to vote in person, by proxy, by directed proxy or by online ballot. The entire process was administered by MK Elections, and a few hours after the meeting, this contractor emailed the official results to the candidates and all shareholders.
The board president, Julia Rosner, reviewed the results and recognized something was wrong. Although she had tendered 65 undirected proxies from shareholders to MK Elections and had received ballots for voting, she realized she had inadvertently neglected to cast the ballots.
The day after the election, Rosner handed MK the ballots she still had in her possession. When MK recalculated the results, three of the four announced winners had lost, and other candidates were elected. Initially, the board was inclined to accept the new results from MK, but there was resistance from a number of the directors. Looking to quell any controversy, the board decided that a new election should take place, and it sent out notices to that effect. However, two shareholders opposed this and took the matter to court, asking that the candidates originally announced as winners be allowed to take their seats, and a new election be prohibited.
The court found that the “the election should only be set aside where it is so clouded with doubt or tainted with questionable circumstances that the standards of fair dealing” require it to take action. The court held that no such doubt or taint had been established at the WVH election. A mistake in voting is not considered an impropriety.
This is consistent with the position of numerous New York courts, which have held that there can be no change once the polls are closed and the winners are announced. If a mistake is noted the next day, the announced results cannot be changed, and the court will not intercede.
The reason these disputes happen is the rush to announce the results the evening of the annual meeting. This is asking for trouble. In many cases, if there was a simple comparison of the number of shareholders who signed in (either by proxy or in person) and the number of ballots, discrepancies might be discovered before it’s too late. Perhaps an adage should be created just for elections at cooperatives and condominiums: Check twice, announce once.
Andrew P. Brucker is a partner at the law firm Armstrong Teasdale. The statements and views in this article are his own and not necessarily those of the firm.
According to a new survey from Schwab Retirement Plan Services, investors consider inflation the biggest obstacle to saving for a comfortable retirement
By Alan Goforth for BenefitsPro
Investors consider inflation the biggest obstacle to saving for a comfortable retirement, according to a new survey from Schwab Retirement Plan Services. Forty-five percent of respondents cited inflation, followed by monthly expenses (35%), stock market volatility (33%), and unexpected expenses (33%).
“Workers have been through a lot over the past two years, and it’s only natural that recent economic and geopolitical turbulence has continued to fuel financial concerns,” says Catherine Golladay, head of Schwab Workplace Financial Services. “While plan participants can’t control inflation or the markets, the good news is they are taking steps to manage their finances with an eye to the future.”
HOAs usually charge fees that add to monthly housing costs.
There are benefits of HOA living despite the fees and restrictions.
When you are buying a house, you’ll likely come across many neighborhoods where there is a homeowners association. HOAs often impose rules about what you can do with your home, and they also charge fees you’ll have to pay each month on top of your mortgage payment.
While the added cost of an HOA may seem undesirable, there are actually a few big benefits of living in a neighborhood with an association. In fact, here are some of the biggest upsides of living someplace with an HOA.
1. The HOA protects your property values
Your property values are affected by the quality of your neighborhood and by how your neighbors maintain their houses. After all, no matter how nice your own property is, no one will want to buy it if it’s next to a slum.
Homeowners associations set and enforce rules related to the upkeep of property in the neighborhood. They may also set other restrictions such as requiring approval before painting a house or adding lawn ornaments. These rules help keep the neighborhood looking nice, which in turn keeps property values higher.
2. The HOA maintains the neighborhood and amenities
HOAs usually maintain common areas, and some neighborhoods with strong associations have lots of amenities such as pools or golf courses.
These features can add value to your home since they are desirable to buyers, and they can also make it nicer for you to live in your neighborhood since you can take advantage of them.
3. Fees may include common utilities and maintenance tasks
In some cases, HOA fees include things like internet service, pool maintenance, or lawn care. When that is the case, it’s convenient to pay one common fee to get many different services rather than having to arrange for them individually and contract with companies to pay for them separately.
In some situations, you may actually end up saving money because it can be cheaper for internet companies or landscaping companies to provide their services to an entire neighborhood rather than to just individual households. The fees you’re paying could actually be a better value than paying for these services privately.
4. The HOA can deal with neighborhood disputes
When people live in close proximity to one another, it’s often inevitable that disputes arise. There could be issues for a huge number of reasons, from barking dogs to lawns that aren’t maintained to loud music playing and more.
When you live in an HOA neighborhood, you don’t have to directly deal with a neighbor who is causing you problems in your enjoyment of your own home. The HOA most likely has regulations related to common nuisances or issues that come up regularly. They’ll take care of addressing the issues that arise among neighbors so you don’t have to sour your relationship with those living near you or cope with the stress of a confrontation.
For all of these reasons, it’s worth considering an HOA neighborhood when you buy a property. Just remember you need to be comfortable with the rules the association sets as you’ll have to live by them too.
A Gen Z TikTok influencer, a millennial manager and a Gen X homeowner with five children walk into a room. That statement may sound like the start of a joke, but it’s also what a typical meeting in a multigenerational organization may look like. The four largest generations—boomers, Gen X, millennials and Gen Z—are currently in the workforce, each with their own unique communication styles and expectations.
Organizations can benefit from employees with diverse backgrounds, but a lack of knowledge about other generations in the workforce can hinder effective teamwork and communication. To successfully lead a multigenerational organization through these challenges, business leaders should work to understand the preferences of their audience, use multiple methods of communication, and unite employees across generations by crafting inclusive messaging.
Below are three strategies business leaders should consider to ensure effective and open multigenerational communication.
Understand Communication Preferences
While published data offers a wealth of conclusions about different generational styles, business leaders should take a step back and consider how best to reach each audience within the company.
Just like every individual has different preferences of communication, regardless of age, each organization’s culture creates a unique messaging environment. For instance, fully remote organizations will face different challenges than hybrid businesses with several in-person days each week.
Gathering the necessary information about communication preferences is as easy as asking your employees. Surveys can be a powerful tool to find out how employees best receive and respond to information. An internal communications survey can identify areas that need more attention and highlight tactics that deliver key messages effectively and inclusively to all employees.
Use Multiple Communication Channels
In any multigenerational organization, business leaders can benefit from sharing key messages across multiple channels and forums of communications to accommodate individual and generational differences.
While some employees will prefer face-to-face interactions, others will tend to choose phone, email or text over face-to-face meetings. Some members of younger generations may prefer face-to-face communication but place a high value on the ability to instant message and text informally for speed of execution. When possible, communicate key message points like quarterly updates or leadership transitions in multiple forums to acknowledge and respect these preferences.
For instance, an in-person, officewide town hall meeting on a major shift in company direction can allow those who feel most at ease with face-to-face communication to voice their opinions. However, it remains equally important to share key points via email or internal digital platforms and accept online submissions from employees who may feel more comfortable communicating in writing.
Unite Employees Through Inclusive Messaging
When possible, business leaders should strive to bring together employees from across generations to deliver inclusive and integrated messaging. If the culture permits different generations to routinely convene only with each other, silos may develop and foster division and misalignment. Each generation has much to teach others, and supporting an environment where teams and meetings are multigenerational can strengthen company culture. You should always deliver major communications initiatives to a diverse blend of multigenerational employees using a variety of methods.
To promote unity, take advantage of communications events to foster interactions between employees. A quarterly presentation of company performance could be followed by a more casual gathering that allows employees from multiple generations to socialize. For a virtual meeting, consider breaking out into smaller discussion groups afterward so employees can share their insights.
By adopting a strategic approach to multigenerational communications, companies can communicate successfully and create a thriving and inclusive corporate culture.
A variety of study aids are available to CMCA exam candidates online at CAMICB.org. Because CAMICB recognizes that people have different learning styles, multiple resources are available in various formats. A quick glance at those resources can be overwhelming. Here, we offer a roadmap designed to help you select and properly use those resources towards a successful outcome.
STEP 1. CMCA Study Guide. Download this FREE guide for an overview of how the CMCA exam was developed and how it’s structured. This is important to developing a study strategy. Here, you will also find the key to your studying success: The CMCA Knowledge
8 Knowledge Areas
Areas. You will be evaluated on these 8 knowledge areas, and understanding your strengths and weaknesses in each area, as well as how each knowledge area is weighted, will help you properly prepare a solid study plan.
STEP 2. CMCA Handbook. Download the FREE handbook for an overview of the program, paying particular attention to:
Section 2: Taking the CMCA Exam highlights the policies and procedures of the exam.
Section 3: CMCA Examination Content and Study Materials offers just that, as well as strategies for standardized test-taking.
STEP 3. If you took CAI’s M-100: The Essentials of Community Association Management, you are not fully prepared to sit for the CMCA exam. The M-100 will provide you with concrete knowledge (i.e., terms and definitions) but will not give you the knowledge to apply those terms and definitions to concepts. For example, What is a Quorum? is not a question you will see on the CMCA exam. You may, however, see a question like this, Quorum requirements conflicts are resolved by which of the following? That doesn’t mean you can skip this step. It’s still important to know the definitions in order to be able to apply them.
STEP 4. Quizlet is a FREE online tool that uses fun games and exercises to test your concrete knowledge. If after reviewing the M-100 course material, you find that your knowledge of terms and definitions is lacking, Quizlet is an excellent way to help you master those key terms and phrases, and prepare you for the next step in your study plan.
STEP 5. Best Practices Reports are FREE resource guides courtesy of the Foundation for Community Association Research. These Reports will help you gain applied knowledge in key areas found on the exam. Each report also contains case studies to help you understand how best practices are applied in real life situations, which is key to grasping an applied knowledge of these topics. If you’re a seasoned manager, spend a little extra time here. What you’ve learned on the job, may not be deemed best practices in the industry.
STEP 6. The CMCA Study Kit is available for purchase from the CAI Bookstore. A great tool for developing applied knowledge, you may purchase individual titles or the entire package depending on your needs.
STEP 7. CMCA Practice Exam is available online at a cost of $25 for one attempt and $40 for two. The Practice Exam includes questions that have been rotated off the exam and offers real time feedback on whether you were right or wrong on a question and why, offering real-world insight into the CMCA exam experience.
All of these materials to prepare you for the CMCA Exam can be found at CAMICB.org on the Exam Preparation web page. We encourage you to spend at least 6-8 weeks preparing for the Exam, and if you have any questions you can contact us at 866-779-CMCA or info@camicb.org.
We’d like to hear from managers who are studying for the exam. What’s working for you? What’s not? Please use the Comments section to let us know how you’re doing!
There are more women aged 25 and older with a bachelor’s degree or higher in the workforce than there were before the COVID-19 pandemic.
There’s been one notable labor-market turnaround since the worst days of the COVID-19 pandemic — and it happened among college-educated women.
Women account for more than half of the college-educated labor force, according to an analysis of federal data released this month by the Pew Research Center, a nonprofit think tank based in Washington, D.C. There are currently more women aged 25 and older with a bachelor’s degree or higher in the workforce than there were before the COVID-19 pandemic: 31.3 million in the second quarter of 2022, or 50.7% of the labor force, versus 29.1 million in 2019.
The number of college-educated men aged 25 and older in the workforce also rose over the same period, to 30.5 million from 29.1 million, although their numbers did not rise at the same rate. “The change occurred in the fourth quarter of 2019 and remains the case today, even though the COVID-19 pandemic resulted in a sharp recession and an overall decline in the size of the nation’s labor force,” Pew senior researcher Richard Fry said.
There is a lot of focus on labor-force participation — amid concerns that people are dropping out of the workforce — and on whether labor-force participation rates will return to pre-pandemic levels, Fry told MarketWatch. “One of the factors bolstering the growth of the women’s college-educated labor force is that college-educated women are the only gender and education group whose labor-force participation rate is back at its pre-pandemic level,” he said.
‘College-educated women are the only gender and education group whose labor force participation rate is back at its pre-pandemic level.’— Pew senior researcher Richard Fry
The pandemic took a toll on both men and women. But the overall share of college-educated women in the labor force is unchanged since before the pandemic, while that share actually declined for men. And the participation rate of college-educated women has increased more than the rate for men over the same period. In short, Fry cited “changes in the composition of the U.S. population, along with changes in labor-force participation.”
Women still face barriers to entering the workforce, and additional challenges once they’ve found a job. For starters, child care remains an expensive monthly cost for families and single working mothers. Women with a bachelor’s degree still only earn roughly 70 cents on the dollar compared to the median annual earnings of a man with a bachelor’s degree, according to the latest Census Bureau figures, and the wage gaps for women of color are often much wider. Higher-paid fields like computers and engineering tend to be dominated by men.
For these reasons, and the fact that men have long occupied the majority of C-suite roles and senior management jobs, it has also taken a long time for the number of college-educated women to surpass men in the workforce. “This shift in the college-educated labor force — as women now comprise a majority — comes around four decades after women surpassed men in the number of Americans earning a bachelor’s degree each year,” Fry added.
The labor market overall is on an upward trajectory. The U.S. added a robust 315,000 new jobs in August, showing that businesses still have a big appetite for labor even as the economy slows and worries about a recession grow. The unemployment rate, meanwhile, rose to 3.7% from 3.5%, the government said this month, mostly because more people entered the labor force in search of work. That was the highest jobless rate in six months.
By Kelly Richardson for The San Diego Union Tribune
Row Of House Models On Blue HOA Cubic Blocks Over Reflective Desk (iStock)
Q: Outside the regularly scheduled board meeting, the directors are meeting to review and accept the treasurer’s developed budget. Can association members attend as observers only? What is the law on meeting outside noticed open board meetings?
— L.B., Martinez
A: The Open Meeting Act (Civil Code Sections 4900-4955) requires all open board meetings be announced at least four days in advance with a posted agenda. A “board meeting” per Civil Code Section 4090 is any time a quorum of the board is, in person or otherwise, discussing anything within the board’s authority. So, if the board is meeting to discuss the budget, that is a “board meeting” per Section 4090 and it should be announced four days ahead. Members must be permitted to attend all open board meetings, so yes, you should be able to observe board budget discussions.
Q: From March 2020 until several months ago, our board meetings were held via Zoom. Now they are in person — which the board says is required under state law — in a poorly ventilated, often crowded room, no masks required or requested. This is causing concern to some homeowners who are concerned about the current extremely contagious COVID variant which can infect even the fully vaccinated and boosted. Is possible to get some special dispensation from the state to permit — or require — meetings by Zoom?
— M.F., Coronado
A: Purely virtual meetings are not allowed except in the event a declared emergency prevents the meeting. However, why not add a virtual component to the in-person meetings? Anyone who is unable to attend physically can still attend virtually, which improves communication and participation. I am increasingly supportive of “hybrid” meetings. Since the cost of setting up hybrid meetings is usually minor (subscription to a virtual meeting platform service and purchasing a conference call microphone), most HOAs can and should benefit.
Q: When the meeting notice was posted for the upcoming board meeting, I asked the management company where the physical location would be. I was told it would be at the management office, which is more than 25 miles away. That seems like an excessive requirement. Is there anything in the Civil Code that requires the physical location to be at the site of the complex or at least somewhere closer than 25-plus miles away?
— E.B., San Diego
A: Nothing in the Davis-Stirling Act addresses the location of board meetings, but Corporations Code Section 7211(a)(5) says that board meetings may be held as stated in the notice of meeting or as stated by the bylaws or board resolution. So, unless the bylaws restrict the meeting location, it could theoretically be many miles away from the project. Some HOAs do not have a suitable place for meetings, and others don’t have a setup conducive to a virtual meeting component (assuming a hybrid meeting), so I do know that many HOAs hold meetings at their management company’s offices. Certainly, there is a point at which the distance is something which should be considered. Finding a suitable meeting place isn’t easy. I have seen clients use/rent rooms in libraries, churches, restaurants, community recreation centers and even car dealerships!
Kelly G. Richardson, Esq., is a fellow of the College of Community Association Lawyers and partner of Richardson Ober LLP, a California law firm known for community association expertise. Submit column questions to Kelly@roattorneys.com. Past columns at www.HOAHomefront.com.
Meetings are broken. Something happened when work moved online in 2020, and opening up the office hasn’t fixed it. Every interaction with colleagues became a video call, and our days became a game of transactional Tetris: Where can I slot in this or that meeting? Now, with policies directing which days of the week to be where, the Tetris has gotten more complex.
In my work helping distributed and hybrid organizations flourish, I see employees commuting only to spend time in near-empty offices or on calls. It feels less like flexibility than a new constraint, and it’s not building the relationships we intended. It’s the worst of both worlds.
There is a better way. Instead of focusing on when and where we meet, we ought to start with why we’re coming together and let that dictate logistics. When I’m asked to help rebuild relationships and strengthen complex collaboration, I begin with foundational advice: The new work calendar isn’t about office or home, it’s about three gathering types and the conditions that serve them best.
Three Types of Gatherings
Why do I call them gatherings and not meetings? Names signal purpose. Meeting has a strong connotation, suggesting people around a conference table (or the online equivalent) and a tight agenda. Gatherings offer multiple purposes and release the idea that we must conduct a time-stamped march to check things off lists.
Transactional gatherings move work forward; relational gatherings strengthen connections; and adaptive gatherings help us address complex or sensitive topics. As transactional gatherings are easier to conduct online, relational and adaptive gatherings have become relatively scarce. Now is a great time to reintroduce and redesign these gatherings, as all had flaws even before the pandemic. Let’s look at the best conditions for all three. While I focus on distributed and hybrid environments, the lessons apply for any organization.
1. Transactional Gatherings
Transactional gatherings are about getting things done. Examples include daily standups, weekly sales updates, and planning meetings. They need three things to be successful:
Shared working documents
Cloud-based tools like Google Docs, Miro, and FigJam are game-changers. If your team hasn’t been using them, now is the time. Because multiple people can edit simultaneously, everyone sees updates in real time, and they far outweigh a whiteboard only a few can see.
Screen parity
Hybrid transactional gatherings — where at least two people are in the same room and the rest are distributed — benefit from screen parity, or having each person appear in an individual tile. As anyone who’s attended a hybrid meeting remotely likely knows, it’s hard to interact with a virtual conference room full of blurry people.
A host on the lookout for signals of participation
While tech adjustments go a long way, hosts have an additional responsibility when not everyone is together: spying signals of participation. A raised hand or a mic going off mute are signals to engage participants. I’ve found it advantageous to add a supplementary role: an engagement lead to support the host in ensuring active, equitable participation. In smaller events, the engagement lead and the host are synonymous. In bigger gatherings, consider appointing separate owners.
2. Relational Gatherings
Relational gatherings are intended to strengthen our connections. Examples historically included offsites, group lunches, or team-building outings. They need three things to be successful:
Clear objectives
Relational gatherings suffer most from “let’s just get everyone together” syndrome: the idea that just throwing people together will suffice. While these types of events can be lovely, they are not relationship builders. Instead, whether you’re convening two people or the whole organization, relational gatherings should be intentionally designed, with clear objectives. Instead of “get to know everyone,” try objectives like:
Learn about career evolutions
Understand driving motivations
Reflect on growth moments
These objectives give people a hook so they can get to know each other more naturally.
Structured activities
Instead of an amorphous free-for-all, structure time deliberately. Split the session into times to reflect (alone) and share (in small groups) through activities like the following:
Draw a map of your career, highlighting pivots.
Share one piece of work-related advice you return to often.
Tell a story of resilience.
Strong relationships are built by laddering up levels of openness, so these activities allow people to choose comfortable levels of exposure. A leadership team who has worked together for years and navigated rocky waters would likely share deeper stories than newcomers at an onboarding event.
If you have a subset of your team together, create a distinct, asynchronous way for non-attendees to engage. For example, for the advice activity, you could ask people to share their example over video in advance.
A mix of people from across functions, levels, or locations
Left to our own devices, we go where we’re comfortable: talking to our teammates, our peers, or those in similar circumstances. But organizations need us to have relationships beyond these silos, which relational gatherings can support by deliberately mixing people who wouldn’t naturally gravitate to each other.
3. Adaptive Gatherings
Adaptive gatherings help us address complex or sensitive topics where the right process or the desired outcome are not clear from the outset. These gatherings require agility and sensitivity. Examples include strategy sessions, innovation sprints, career conversations, or navigating the organizational impact of a societal issue. To be successful, they require three conditions:
A malleable, distinct environment
When I was at the design firm IDEO, where almost every client gathering was adaptive, we preferred rooms separate from team meeting spaces. Ideal were spaces where furniture was moveable, people could mill around, and there was no formal hierarchy implied (board rooms: out!). Space influences how people interact, so the location was the first clue to participants that this was not a run-of-the-mill conversation.
If you’re online, break out of video boxes. Design brainstorming sessions with video off and the focus on a digital jamboard. And try to host delicate conversations (where body language matters) with people sitting on couches or chairs rather than at desks, with the camera farther back to reduce intensity and allow for full-body signals.
A sense of safety
Historically, difficult or sensitive conversations happened in person, so we could watch body language and use physical surroundings to create a sense of safety. But we’ve learned over the pandemic that this isn’t always necessary — or desirable. An example is sensitive career conversations. While your instinct may be to hold these meetings in person, several employees have told me they prefer these discussions online. The screen helps them hold their emotions in check, providing a greater sense of control. Allow employees autonomy over where these are held (some may prefer online, others a walk-and-talk).
Release valves to dissolve tensions
Often, complex problems have time pressure, and release valves can help. To navigate to conclusions from a place of calm, create separation between discussing options and making decisions. In the room, that might be a coffee break with a shared laugh about something off topic. Online, encourage everyone to get outside and not think about the issue. This change in focus is not expendable, but rather a critical component of a successful outcome.
In a distributed organization I led, we needed to build a new guiding framework after a charged incident. To dissipate tension, we altered cadence and structure. First, we hosted a small digital round table to reflect on the incident (to allow emotions to flow when assessing the pain point). Next, we held one-on-ones with various individuals to understand diverse needs (the intimacy helped people feel more comfortable being vulnerable). Finally, we hosted a session to craft our new framework (by then, the emotions from the first two stages had sufficient space to dissipate).
What should you do if your gathering is all (or none) of the above?
While these use cases benefit from different conditions, it doesn’t mean you can’t combine them. An example is an offsite slated to build relationships, address complex strategic issues, and get work done. Set separate conditions for each: Mix and match people who wouldn’t naturally gravitate to each other, allow strategic discussions to have breathing room, and use distinct spaces for each type of activity.
Other events may not feel like they are transactional, relational, or adaptive gatherings. That’s okay, too. Because the path to an effective gathering is always to ask: Why are we meeting? What are we trying to accomplish? And to let each need have its own space and place. You may be surprised by the rhythm of when to convene in person. While it will vary by team needs, it’s more likely to be on a monthly, quarterly, or project cadence than weekly.
And if you can’t make organization-wide change, you can still impact your own gatherings. Within a policy that dictates where you should be, not why, reorient how you conduct gatherings by shifting your priorities from the logistics of your calendar to the needs of your people.
Amy Bonsall is the CEO of Collective, a platform that helps distributed organizations and their people flourish. Prior, Amy was an IDEO and Old Navy executive. She’s been on the pages and stages of Entrepreneur, IDEO.com, SXSW, Singularity University, and more, covering flourishing at work, working from anywhere, distributed organizations, and behavioral prototyping. She co-teaches a course on Designing a Business, hosted by IDEOU. Follow Amy on Instagram.